Welcome to Citarella
Citarella, a New York City treasure located on Broadway, has been delighting food enthusiasts for decades with its exceptional quality seafood, baked goods, and artisanal prepared foods. Founded on the principles of freshness and excellence, Citarella stands out with its handcrafted dishes, such as the signature Guiseppe's Chicken Meatballs and Italian almond bars that have become local favorites. The market's vibrant atmosphere and welcoming staff enhance the shopping experience, making it a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike. Each visit promises a blend of culinary artistry and the rich flavors of Italian heritage, ensuring that every dish is a celebration of taste.
-
2135 Broadway, New York, NY 10023 Hotline: (212) 874-0383
Welcome to Citarella, a true gem nestled in the heart of New York City, at 2135 Broadway. Renowned as a premier seafood market and bakery, Citarella offers an exquisite selection of gourmet foods that celebrate the rich flavors of Italian cuisine. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor exploring the Upper West Side, Citarella beckons with its promise of high-quality ingredients and exceptional service.
Stepping into Citarella, you're greeted by the vibrant atmosphere and the aroma of freshly baked goods, making it a delightful destination for food enthusiasts. The store's commitment to quality is evident in every offering, from their handcrafted beef entrees to their delightful baked goods. One standout dish is the 24 oz. Giuseppe's Beef Meatballs, a classic dish crafted with prime ground beef, coated in a rich garlic tomato sauce. It's a hearty choice perfect for any occasion, priced at $22.99.
For poultry lovers, the Guiseppe's Chicken Meatballs are another must-try. These tender morsels, made from fresh ground chicken and enhanced with a fresh garlic tomato sauce, are equally delightful and comfortably priced at $22.99. If you crave comfort food, the Turkey Meatloaf, lovingly crafted with a mix of turkey, breadcrumbs, and a luscious brown sauce, is an ideal selection at $22.99.
Vegetarian options like the Eggplant Parmigiana, with its golden-brown crust and rich Citarella tomato sauce, cater to plant-based enthusiasts and costs $25.99, showcasing Citarella's dedication to inclusivity in their menu offerings. Customers rave about the fast service and the beautiful presentation of prepared foods, making it easy to grab a quick bite or dinner for the family.
What truly sets Citarella apart is not just the food, but the experience. Customers have shared heartfelt stories of the warm service, with special mentions of staff like Frank, whose friendliness shines even on bustling days. As one customer put it, "The store has always been clean. Friendliness of employees can be hit or miss." Yet, it’s clear that when you find a friendly face, it enhances the visit.
Lastly, don’t miss out on their beautiful selection of baked goods, including the famous Italian almond bars, which have become a hit among patrons looking for that perfect sweet treat. As a customer noted, though they’re a bit pricey, they are "the closest to my favorite Sienese ricciarelli cookies that I’ve tasted in NYC," proving that quality has its value.
No matter what brings you to Citarella, the store feels like a welcoming oasis amidst the bustling city—an NYC classic that promises something for everyone. So, whether you're picking up fresh seafood, indulging in baked goods, or stocking up on hearty entrees, it's worth the visit. You might just find yourself leaving with a smile and a delicious meal in hand!
36 years + still great and hilarious stories to go with the service. Great owners and staff.
Beautiful store with high quality foods. Check out the prepared foods. Service is fast.
A wonderfully run store especially on hectic shopping days like Thanksgiving! Special shout out to Frank who was extremely friendly and helpful today. Thankful to have Citarella in the neighborhood!
The Italian almond bars are always a hit when I bring these to work or to a party! You can always find boxes of these cookies in front of the deli section near the store entrance. It's not cheap, close to $20 for a box, but these are the closest to my favorite Sienese ricciarelli cookies that I've tasted in NYC. If you love anything almond, almond extract, chewy on the inside, a bit solid on the outside, you're going to love these.
Before I moved to the East Side I lived on West 74th Street and Broadway. I spent a lot of time in Citarella. I love the Bakery! I always return when I'm shopping in this neighborhood. While it is pricey, to me it's worth the price. Everything is fresh. The store has always been clean. Friendliness of employees can be hit or miss. They just want to give you what you want, not make friends or chit chat. I don't blame them. I love the gift baskets. When I have the need for a gift for someone special this is my go to store. The receiver of my gift has never been disappointed. There you have it. It's a NYC Classic. If you live nearby or are just visiting, take a walk through. I bet you can't leave without buying something.